Sell Your Cards to On-Board Gaming

We buy Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, One Piece, Lorcana, and Riftbound singles — every day, in store and online.

Two ways to sell

  1. Submit online — browse our buylist, see cash and store-credit offers for each card, and submit your list before you come in.
  2. Walk in — bring your cards to the shop during business hours and we'll go through them at the counter. Walk-in appraisals are limited to 10 cards or fewer and are subject to staff availability — please call or message the store ahead of time to ensure prompt service. For larger collections, submit through the buylist or contact the store to schedule an appointment.

Start a Buylist

Cash or store credit — your choice

Store credit offers are always higher than cash. Exact offers for both are shown per card on the buylist.

Before you submit

  • Reserve List and other high-value or older cards may not appear as available on the buylist. Contact the store directly for trade information.
  • Sort your cards so your stacks match the order they appear in your cart — it streamlines processing your submission.
  • Note your Buylist ID number after submitting. You'll need it if you have questions or need to reach us about your submission.
  • Check conditions carefully against the grading guide below (see also TCGplayer's condition guide). Accurate condition descriptions ensure a smooth evaluation.

Selling policies

  • All offers are confirmed in store — our staff verify each card's condition against the grading guide below before payout.
  • Bulk sales and large collections: we do not take bulk collections (commons, rares, etc.). If you have a large collection of cards valued at $5 or more per card, collections are bought by appointment only — email shop@on-boardgaming.com or call (760) 566-6782 to arrange one.
  • You must be 18 or older to sell.